Green with envy
Posted by Ron Coleman on October 17, 2007
The New York Observer catalogs, along with a scurrilously hideous caricature of the candidate’s wife, the horror — the horror! — local New York libs are experiencing at the prospect of their hated former mayor as the likely GOP candidate, and very maybe
possibly winning candidate, for the presidency:
All presidential candidates have some element of hometown opposition—constituents angry about a factory closing, politicians spiteful about losing a bill or an election. But no candidate engenders as much local animus as Mr. Giuliani, whose terms as mayor were characterized by a series of spectacular running battles with various, mostly liberal constituencies.
For the first months of his candidacy for president, prominent progressives in New York mocked the notion that a pro-choice, immigration-friendly serial husband with a history of opposition to guns would have a shot at the Republican nomination.
But now, with Mr. Giuliani up nearly 10 percentage points in national polls and unexpectedly competitive in the early primary states of New Hampshire and South Carolina, a mixture of nervousness and disbelief is running through the ranks of his old antagonists.
“People say, ‘Still?’” said Mark Green, a former New York City public advocate and persistent foil to Mr. Giuliani. “If the other 49 [states] knew what we knew, he wouldn’t be in the ballpark, much less winning the game.”
It is to laugh — Mark Green! He would surely be proud, at all the East Side dinner parties, to be considered a “persistent foil” to Mr. Giuliani. But the word “tinfoil” keeps bursting through one’s mental associations, for as any local will tell you, Green is identified mainly as one of the persistent losers of New York politics, a liberal Democrat without a pogrom to his credit who still managed to lose a New York City mayoral election to a billionaire Republican in New York City. Green is most notable for finding last-ditch municipal teats, such as the preposterous political post of “public advocate,” onto which to latch, so as never have to work an honest day in his life.
Foil, indeed. To hear a strikeout king like Mark Green talk about ballparks and games — this is truly local color!











jaymaster said
That is an extremely interesting article. I am amazed that those folks have the temerity to speak so openly about what they are trying to do to bring Rudy down.
And speaking of caricatures, I find it hard to believe that such intelligent political minds actually think that the true Republican base is the “I won’t vote for no big city, pro choice, dee-vor-cee!” And all they need to do is get the word out about the “Real Rudy”, and he’ll never stand a chance of making it through the primaries. Maybe they have lived in their echo chambers so long that they really believe that. But I doubt it.
It wasn’t spoken in the article (of course), but it’s pretty obvious what’s going on here. They can blame their animosity on the “old nemesis” meme, but that’s only part of the story. They know that Rudy would mop the floor with Hillary in the general election. So they’re pulling out all the stops now, to try to keep him from ever making it that far.
And the best hope they have of making that happen is to get the hard core social conservative Republicans, and the gun nuts (like me!) worried enough to kill Rudy off in the primaries.
So I expect wave after wave of pieces like this. 10-20 years ago, when the Dem’s controlled the MSM, this strategy might have worked. But I’m not so sure about today.
Interesting times…..
Ara said
They know that Rudy would mop the floor with Hillary in the general election.
He’d be a tough opponent, no doubt about it. This is because many people make a fundamental mistake regarding Giuliani: they waaaay overestimate the power of hypocrisy as a exclusionary factor. In other words, “values” is over-rated as an issue.
And in that same vein, I think that the NYFD will be vilified as traitors and fifth columnists before this election cycle is over. I’m just saying.
Me? I think, with Giuliani, the bottom line is about race. His followers perceive him to the be the #1 guy to stick it to ’em. If you catch my drift.
New York libs are experiencing [horror] at the prospect of their hated former mayor as the likely GOP candidate, and very possibly winning candidate…
It isn’t just libs in the city. Across the entire state, current polling shows New Yorkers overwhelmingly favor Hillary right now.