Likelihood of Success

Ron Coleman’s pretty good blog

Fiction is stranger than non-fiction

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 13, 2007

Admirers of left-wing propagandist Michael Moore who shot a picture about his work called “Manufacturing Dissent” found him less cooperative about being in their documentary than former GM head Roger Smith, whom Moore depicted falsely as being unavailable and evasive in Moore’s award-winning “Roger and Me.” Notwithstanding the fact that Moore patently misled audiences about Smith’s alleged non-cooperation, Debbie Melnyk and Rick Caine still consider the obese multimillionaire “populist” and Jimmy Carter companion something of a hero:

“We’re a bit disappointed and disillusioned with Michael,” Melnyk said, “but we are still very grateful to him for putting documentaries out there in a major way that people can go to a DVD store and they’re right up there alongside dramatic features.”

It sounds as if they’d be grateful to Mark McGwire for “the concept” of breaking Roger Maris’s single-season home run record, too. Documentaries are supposed to be cinematic depictions of the truth. Of course they never really have been, and still hardly ever are. In fact every photograph, much less every moving picture — which modern people consider the sina qua non of “proof” — is a lie, a choice of framing, lighting, perspective, or worse. The same goes for print and other forms of journalism.

That doesn’t make these endeavors worthless — far from it. But like so much else in our culture, we have to acculturate ourselves to real reality: “Non-fiction,” whether by word, lens or “virtual reality,” is still someone else’s narrative.

Is there any hope for objectivity? Only one: Free expression, of course — the opportunity to contradict the chosen narrative*, to show the unlit angle, to interview the neglected witnesses. The Internet provides that opportunity as never before, so, of course, tyrants fear it. By all means give Melnyk and Caine credit for telling at least another slice of the story, despite how it reflects on a man they have found a way, despite his wretched dishonesty, to admire.

—

*Link updated.

6 Responses to “Fiction is stranger than non-fiction”

  1. It sounds as if they’d be grateful to Mark McGwire for “the concept” of breaking Roger Maris’s single-season home run record, too.

    Roger Maris would be very surprised to learn that McGwire broke Ruth’s single season home run record.

    Ed.: Whoa-ho, Nieporent! You believe that Maris bunk? He was on the juice, too!
    Ok, fixed. It was late.

  2. I think ‘lie’ is a bit strong. Of course, a photo can be a lie, but it is not necessarily so. What it always is, however, is a selective and selected version of reality. That version is subjective to the photographer and equally subjective to the viewer.

    While a photo can never be ‘the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth,’ it need not be interpreted as a ‘lie’.

  3. John, the reason I say it’s a lie is that it is not only not the whole truth, but it simulates reality so powerfully that it suggests that it is. In this way art is superior — we know it is interpretation, selection, distillation at the outset.

  4. soccer dad's avatar

    soccer dad said

    For all of Moore’s phony complaints about being silenced by Disney in deference to the Brothers Bush (debunked by Edward Jay Epstein as well as Moore’s own admission) little is said about his own foray into censorship. In the 80’s he edited Mother Jones for a few months. When Paul Berman submitted an article that the magazine had commissioned prior to Moore’s appointment, Moore spiked it. The article had been critical of the Sandinistas, and Moore wouldn’t have that. Paul Mulshine of the Star Ledger wrote about it in 2003, A Stupid White Man and a Smart One.

    The differences between Berman and Moore are illustrative of just how far the left has fallen since the glory days of the 1960s. Berman came of age as a Columbia radical at a time when radicals were supposed to read lots of books and think lots of thoughts. That time is past, however, and the left now looks up to such dubious icons as Moore, the director of the Oscar- winning “Bowling for Columbine” and the author of the purportedly nonfiction best- seller “Stupid White Men.”

    The two had a confrontation in 1986 that is instructive. At the time, Berman was a respected writer of impeccable leftist credentials. The leftist Mother Jones magazine commissioned him to go to Nicaragua and write about the Sandinistas. Once in Nicaragua, Berman used his gifts of political analysis to deduce that the Sandinistas were in fact violating a good number of the principles of liberal democracy and were tending toward Leninism. He wrote an article for Mother Jones stating the problem and what he perceived to be the solution.

    Unfortunately, by the time Berman submitted the article, the new editor was a guy from Michigan named Michael Moore, an auto worker’s son who had edited a liberal publication based in Flint. Moore declared that he would not run Berman’s article because “Reagan could easily hold it up, saying, ‘See, even Mother Jones agrees with me.'”

    “He tried to censor me,” said Berman when I got him on the phone the other day. “Truths seem as simple as black and white to him, and he has no ability to see complexity. He’s a very ideological guy and not a very well-educated guy.”

    Hopefully that quote doesn’t violate copyright laws.

  5. Much like Stalin, once someone has spent a great deal of time and energy espousing their virtue, it is hard to come to the cold hard truth that they are not all they are cracked up to be.

  6. Jack's avatar

    Jack said

    “ebony pissing”

    Well, I’ll tell ya…the internet never fails to disappoint, does it Akfapami?

Leave a Reply