Likelihood of Success

Ron Coleman’s pretty good blog

Archive for the ‘Medialites’ Category

Backup, climb down

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 13, 2007

Robert Kagan writes in the Washington Post:

A front-page story in The Post last week suggested that the Bush administration has no backup plan in case the surge in Iraq doesn’t work. I wonder if The Post and other newspapers have a backup plan in case it does.
Leading journalists have been reporting for some time that the war was hopeless, a fiasco that could not be salvaged by more troops and a new counterinsurgency strategy. …
No one is asking American journalists to start emphasizing the “good” news. All they have to do is report what is occurring, though it may conflict with their previous judgments. Some are still selling books based on the premise that the war is lost, end of story. But what if there is a new chapter in the story?

I wonder if it will make any difference. The only way it could is if the White House or the GOP were up to pushing the positive story. Evidently they aren’t, and never have been, which is an utter mystery to me. And we might well say that if you don’t have the ability not only to sell a war before it begins, but also during its course — you are not prepared to wage it, or to win it. Hat tip to Bizzy Blog.

Posted in Medialites, Politics and Poker | 1 Comment »

Fiction is stranger than non-fiction

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 13, 2007

Admirers of left-wing propagandist Michael Moore who shot a picture about his work called “Manufacturing Dissent” found him less cooperative about being in their documentary than former GM head Roger Smith, whom Moore depicted falsely as being unavailable and evasive in Moore’s award-winning “Roger and Me.” Notwithstanding the fact that Moore patently misled audiences about Smith’s alleged non-cooperation, Debbie Melnyk and Rick Caine still consider the obese multimillionaire “populist” and Jimmy Carter companion something of a hero:

“We’re a bit disappointed and disillusioned with Michael,” Melnyk said, “but we are still very grateful to him for putting documentaries out there in a major way that people can go to a DVD store and they’re right up there alongside dramatic features.”

It sounds as if they’d be grateful to Mark McGwire for “the concept” of breaking Roger Maris’s single-season home run record, too. Documentaries are supposed to be cinematic depictions of the truth. Of course they never really have been, and still hardly ever are. In fact every photograph, much less every moving picture — which modern people consider the sina qua non of “proof” — is a lie, a choice of framing, lighting, perspective, or worse. The same goes for print and other forms of journalism.

That doesn’t make these endeavors worthless — far from it. But like so much else in our culture, we have to acculturate ourselves to real reality: “Non-fiction,” whether by word, lens or “virtual reality,” is still someone else’s narrative.

Is there any hope for objectivity? Only one: Free expression, of course — the opportunity to contradict the chosen narrative*, to show the unlit angle, to interview the neglected witnesses. The Internet provides that opportunity as never before, so, of course, tyrants fear it. By all means give Melnyk and Caine credit for telling at least another slice of the story, despite how it reflects on a man they have found a way, despite his wretched dishonesty, to admire.

—

*Link updated.

Posted in Ars Longa, Medialites | 6 Comments »

Imus redeems entire career

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 11, 2007

Breathtaking. Unprecedented. Fearless. Historic. Excerpt:

Imus: Let me interrupt you for a second, but this is nonsense, Senator Schumer. I want to be respectful, but you can’t possibly be serious and suggest — I mean I’m not a fool. You can’t suggest to me that because the Democrats are now in power that something is going to be done about Walter Reed and about the mess in the Veterans Administration and all of this, and that if the Democrats hadn’t taken control of Congress that nothing would have been done. That’s preposterous; of course it would have.

Schumer: Well, something would have been done if the story would have gotten out . . .

Imus: Here’s another question. Have you ever been over to Walter Reed?

Schumer: Ahh, not in a while, no.

Imus: How long has it been since you’ve been over there?

Schumer: Oh, before Iraq.

Imus: So, before Iraq since you’ve been over to see the soldiers. So, we have elected you — first in the Congress and now in the Senate — and you’ve got a bill now to do something we’ll get to in a minute; but you haven’t even been to Walter Reed Hospital.

Schumer: No, no, no. But I have visited regularly the veterans’ hospitals throughout my state. That’s where I have focused on . . .

There’s much more. As to Imus — I guess there is something to be said for making so much money that you simply don’t care any more. On the other hand, Schumer is the Senate’s most Jewish Jew (sorry, Joe — nothing personal — it’s really a compliment, in a way — see you at the kiddush). And we do know what the “I Man” thinks about them. That’s the only reason I can think of that Imus challenged Schumer head-on while he’s usually pretty obsequious to his left-wing guests (and new friend anti-“neoconservative” Pat Buchanan).

You know what? It’s worth it.

(Via Instapundit.)

Posted in Medialites, Politics and Poker | Leave a Comment »

Oil’s well

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 7, 2007

GusherTigerHawk is impressed that even the New York Times admits that the oft-repeated, largely political trope that “oil production has already peaked” is certainly baloney. Tim Blair calls its adherents “abundance denialists” (cleverly paralleling Ellen Goodman).

All you had to do was read anything by Julian Simon back when we were in college to know what rubbish all the “we’re running out! we’re running out” business is. It was guys like Simon who inspired me to major in economics — a discipline founded on dismally mistaken premises about scarcity, but which overcame its humble beginnings and became remarkably good at modeling, understanding and predicting how stuff we need comes to the market and why.

But TigerHawk and Blair are on the money about the cultural point: When even the Times writes the obituary of an exercise in sloppy liberal economics, that well has for sure run dry.

IOWAHAWK Bumper sticker

Posted in Gelt, Medialites | 3 Comments »

Pastelogram: Plan59.com’s Advertising Blog

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 7, 2007

Pure pleasure!

Posted in Americana, Blogophilia, Medialites | Leave a Comment »

Russia contains multitudes on strategic defense

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 6, 2007

Containing multitudes

Yahoo! News reports that a top Russian officer claims, “Russia’s bomber force would have no trouble destroying planned US missile defense sites in Europe, its head said Monday as the country’s security council warned of new policies to counter NATO.” The quote:

“Since the components of the anti-missile defence system are weakly protected, all types of our aircraft are capable of using electronic countermeasures against them and physically destroying them,” Interfax news agency quoted Lieutenant General Igor Khvorov as saying.

Well, of course he says that. Strategic defense, and countermeasures to it, are very much a mind game — you know, “strategic”? — and it costs Ivan nothing to put doubt into the minds of policymakers and commanders about the efficacy of a potentially devastating shift in the balance of power.

The funny part is this:

The Kremlin has fiercely protested US plans to install an anti-missile system in Poland and the Czech Republic.

I see. “It doesn’t really work. It doesn’t affect us. Thanks for wasting your money on it. Ha, what suckers. Go ahead. Make my day.

“HOW DARE YOU!”

So given that the “How dare you” is basically an admission that in fact Russia is quite upset about this deployment, and an acknowledgment that it probably affects the strategic balance after all, what exactly is the intended message? It’s the same. They’re just betting that the opposition parties in the U.S., the Democrats and the mainstream press, will do as they did during the Cold War to whoever opposed assertive defense policies: Listen to what our adversaries say and ignore what they do.

A bad bet? Not hardly at all. As things chill up with neo-czarist Russia, expect the deployment of anti-ballistic-missile technology to get more attention. Next chapter: How it harms the children.

UPDATE: And for heaven’s sake, don’t ask anyone in uniform what they think about it.

Posted in Medialites, Stragety | Leave a Comment »

Ann H. Coulter, Will You Please Go Now!

Posted by David M. Nieporent on March 6, 2007

In 1972, Dr. Seuss (who was born 103 years ago this week) wrote a book called Marvin K. Mooney, Will You Please go Now! A few years later, as the Watergate scandal dragged on to its painful end, columnist Art Buchwald reprinted the book’s text, substituting “Richard M. Nixon” for the title character.

I was going to let the whole Ann Coulter CPAC mess pass without comment, since it happened a couple of days before I started on this blog (eons in blogospheric time), and I figured that there wasn’t anything that needed to be said that hadn’t been said. But tonight I saw this article, in which she not only failed to shut up, but promised that she wouldn’t:

“Apparently our top three Republican nominees aren’t that smart,” Coulter said. “And by the way, if they’re going to start apologizing for everything I say, they better keep that statement handy cause there’s going to be a lot more in the next year.”

All this statement does is confirm my comment and complaint about Coulter from the day of her CPAC speech: everything she does is about her. I don’t particularly care what effect Coulter’s statements might have on the 2008 campaign, nor do I harbor any illusions that in the absence of Coulter, the campaign would be a highbrow, Whig-Clio style political debate about Big Ideas. Still, it would be nice if it weren’t about Ann Coulter.

Unlike Buchwald, I don’t have permission from Mr. Geisel to reprint the whole text, so I’ll just choose this representative excerpt:

Just go.
Go.
Go!
I don’t care how.
You can go by foot.
You can go by cow.
Ann H. Coulter will you please go now!

And hopefully that will be the last time I ever have to address the subject of that woman.

Posted in Medialites, Politics and Poker | 5 Comments »

Cui?, Bono?

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 5, 2007

Advertising Age reports: “Costly Red Campaign Reaps Meager $18 Million.” Walking around New York City, I was impressed with the brand-development demonstrated by this $100 million campaign. Famous, beautiful people in Red Gap stuff, telling us to “Buy Red.” Fantastic simultaneous investment and expenditure of brand equity, utilizing not only Gap but Motorola and Apple — great brands building a new, greater brand for something even greaterly greater!

Okay, one slight problem.

Looking at the ads — on billboards, bus shelters, phone booths — I had no idea what they were for. What Red? Red what?

No message. No content.

In fact, even reading the Advertising Age article linked to above, you still have no idea what the point of this campaign was until five or so paragraphs down into the article! Evidently it’s something to do with AIDS. Or Africa. I still don’t know. Guess what: They — it — he — who? — doesn’t even tell you on the RED homepage.

It’s an arrogance thing, I think.

(Cross-posted on LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION)

Posted in Gelt, Medialites | Leave a Comment »

That settles it

Posted by Ron Coleman on March 2, 2007

Weekend at Osama'sTaliban Official: Bin Laden Is Alive.

I wasn’t buying it when they were showing OBL’s vacation videos during the year after 9/11, which everyone — everyone but the CIA, whose opinion is also entirely counter-indicative of the actual truth — knew had been taken in Tora Bora before it was leveled, if not earlier. I wasn’t buying it in the last year when they haven’t even dragged out the latest 8-track of his supposed voice, which itself was absurd: If he were alive, you know they’d put him on the screen.

Just the whole thing is preposterous. (My word of the year, sorry.) But now that they’ve come out and announced the contrary, short of his head in a basket — which, really, who among us really wants any part of? — I can’t imagine what else you’d want.

UPDATE: I have never felt so sure of myself on something like this!

UP-UP-UPDATE: Dead men tell no tales.

Posted in Medialites, Orient, Politics and Poker | 1 Comment »