Likelihood of Success

Ron Coleman’s pretty good blog

Archive for the ‘Medialites’ Category

Ticket to totalitarianism

Posted by Ron Coleman on November 25, 2007

NewsBusters prints this excerpt from the transcript of NPR’s review of “Redacted” (via Instapundit):

The rape scene has led to a familiar charge, that De Palma is a misogynist who relishes violence against women. . . .
Another charge is that he’s anti-American or anti-troops. But it’s an act of sympathy to suggest that soldiers on their third tours of duty in a place where they have no knowledge of the culture, where they can’t tell who’s on their side and who wants to blow them up, stand a good chance of losing both their moral compass and their minds. Here, and in “Casualties of War,” De Palm[a] is dramatizing the idea that even decent people in such circumstances can convince themselves they’re entitled to do anything.

Here lies the road to the complete inversion of morality. As an “act of sympathy” for the troops, DePalma is supposedly taking the position that even the worst actors in the world — U.S. troops committing atrocities while on an imperialistic mission — are no worse than morally exempt from blame for such atrocities because of the moral incoherence all around them. The logic is unassailable:

  1. Bad guys might be good guys.
  2. Good guys might be bad guys.
  3. Hey, this is hard!
  4. Let’s rape someone.

stalin.jpgThis aligns well with the leftist conception that people the world ’round do not make their own choices at all, but rather are zombies. In America, choiceless voters are under the sway of Rush Limbaugh, religious fundamentalism, and Karl Rove. In the Middle East, suicide bombers are compelled to murder housewives and schoolchildren by their plight or by their rage. But it is relatively novel to see the left apply this to the faceless, heartless automatons of the U.S. military, even in the commission of their fictional outrages. Naturally we can expect NPR to lobby for the release of all soldiers incarcerated for improper conduct in the Iraqi theater immediately.

Soon we will recognize that everything — everything! — is George W. Bush’s fault, and that individual conscience is merely a bourgeois construct of kapital. It is so much simpler.

Cross-posted at Right Wing News.

Posted in Americana, Ars Longa, Medialites, O Mores! | 2 Comments »

The masses are asses

Posted by Ron Coleman on November 25, 2007

William Teach makes a compelling case.

Posted in Americana, Medialites, Sisyphus | 3 Comments »

In the bunker

Posted by Ron Coleman on November 23, 2007

The Weekly Standard (via Glenn) on left-wing denial of the improvemement in Iraq:

Of course, the left-wing nutroots live in their own self-contained universe.

The real question: are congressional Democrats really going to stay in the bunker with them through November 2008?

I think there’s another question: Whither the mainstream media? Answer that one, and then see where the one posed by the Standard goes.

Posted in Medialites, Orient, Politics and Poker | 3 Comments »

The stacked debate

Posted by Ron Coleman on November 17, 2007

The MSM giveth, and the MSM taketh away — they gaveth this one to Hillary, and the blogs — right and left — are screaming bloody murder!  Not only is Wolf (or perhaps, “Puppy”) Blitzer’s tender loving care raising eyebrows, but so is the utter preposterousness of having the post-debate analysis on CNN delivered by three people of whom two are former or present Clinton staffers — and, of course, not even mentioning it in the discussion.

But Noel Sheppard gets to the real heart of it:

Of course, the truly delicious hypocrisy is that these same folks haven’t in any way been angered by Carville, Gergen, or [Anderson] Cooper’s continual rants the past seven years against President Bush, members of his administration, and any politician with an “R” next to his or her name. Those opinions were certainly impartial, and by no means affected by any prior political affiliation.

Throw in George Stephanopoulos, even Patrick Buchanan — there are plenty of others presented to the public on the small screen as fair brokers but who have in fact been personally and professionally part of the political scene in active, i.e. non-journalistic, roles.  If any other field of endeavor had this much revolving-door logrolling going on as the mainstream media, the journos would be huffing and puffing with indignation.  At least give the New York Times credit on this one for calling out CNN — guess they’re sore they didn’t get into the game.

Fourth Estate indeed!

Posted in Medialites, Politics and Poker | 2 Comments »

Ben Stein still all about Intelligence

Posted by Ron Coleman on November 12, 2007

I’ve been back and forth on the topic of Ben Stein for well over 20 years. I loved his writing from the time I was first exposed to it, and he used to be human-sized enough to correspond with me by email when he just wrote for the old American Spectator, but oddly enough when I would challenge him — gingerly — on religious issues (he is Jewish, as I am), he would stop (and eventually did) stop writing back. Okay, I get it. Celebrity, kind of.

His writing is certainly idiosyncratic, and I don’t agree with everything he says. But he says it very well, very sincerely and he’s mostly right, and very original.

But he just may win me back over with this — his crusade against the crusade against Intelligent Design. He even has a blog about it. I need to do some homework to figure out the relationship between Ben Stein and God, but evidently he’s, not surprisingly, kept an open mind about it… unlike some people. Stein told the New York Times:

Mr. Stein, a prolific author who has acted in movies like “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” and appeared on television programs including “Win Ben Stein’s Money” on Comedy Central, said in a telephone interview that he accepted the producers’ invitation to participate in the film not because he disavows the theory of evolution — he said there was a “very high likelihood” that Darwin was on to something — but because he does not accept that evolution alone can explain life on earth.

He said he also believed the theory of evolution leads to racism and ultimately genocide, an idea common among creationist thinkers. If it were up to him, he said, the film would be called “From Darwin to Hitler.”

Well, of course, just as we can’t say that the theory of evolution is not valid because it leads to atheism, we can’t say that if it leads to racism and genocide, it also must be empirically incorrect. As he says, surely Darwin is onto something, and, short of unethical experimentation, we should probably always let science take us where it goes. But he and the filmmakers are challenging a cultural moment here, not arguing the merits of the debate, from what I can tell (I can also tell where the comments section is going to go notwithstanding that caveat), and I can’t wait for the picture to come out.

Posted in Faith and Works, Medialites | 45 Comments »

The rule of law triumphs

Posted by Ron Coleman on October 18, 2007

This’ll teach Time!

Posted in Jocularity, Medialites | Leave a Comment »

Advertisement for Himself

Posted by Ron Coleman on October 17, 2007

Norman Mailer is in the hospital. “He’s not in very good shape. It’s breaking my heart,” his ex-wife Carol Mailer told the New York Post yesterday.

I hadn’t thought of the old man in a long time, until the picture above started glowering at me on all the newsstands in New York, from the cover of New York magazine, which announces thereon that Mailer has started his own new religion, kind of:

In a six-decade career, Norman Mailer has written thirteen novels, nineteen works of nonfiction, two poetry collections, and one play. He’s directed four movies. He ran for mayor of New York, and in the living room of his Brooklyn Heights home, he built, in three weeks, with two friends, a vast Lego city, incorporating some 15,000 pieces, known as the city of the future, seeming to take as much pride in it as in any of his other creations. But even at 84, he has a vast ambition. And now he has created something like a religion. In a new book, On God, a dialogue with one of his literary executors, Michael Lennon, he lays out his highly personal vision of what the universe’s higher truths might look like, if we were in a position to know them. But his theology is not theoretical to him. After eight decades, it is what he believes to be true. He expects no adherents, and does not profess to be a prophet, but he has worked to forge his beliefs into a coherent catechism.

I doubt it. But it appears he may find out very soon.

Posted in Faith and Works, Medialites | 2 Comments »

Jimmy Carter does nothing

Posted by Ron Coleman on October 3, 2007

Moral equivocationist Jimmy Carter and his celebrity friends get humiliated by Sudanese thugs — and the headline? “Jimmy Carter faces down Sudanese officials.”

Well, he did yell at one who tried to stop him in Sudan, when he wanted to go somewhere that “wasn’t on the program.” Then he “compromised”… agreed to talk to the guy they wouldn’t let him see some other time, some other place… who, of course, at that time and that place, never showed.

That’s “facing down”? More like face down. More like our tough old friend, Give ’em Heck Jimmy.

Maybe he should go yell at the Jews about “apartheid” again. They’ll usually flinch a little.

Posted in Medialites, Oppression | 2 Comments »

Self-betrayal

Posted by Ron Coleman on September 25, 2007

Joe Gandelman on the Times‘s ham-fisted MoveOn / Petraeus play:

What’s mind-boggling is that in this highly politicized, polarized, people-looking-for-a-rant atmosphere someone at the Times could approve such language without anticipating that it would trigger howls of protest — not just from Republicans, conservatives and the White House but from all Americans who also decry and condemn any kind of political hate speech — such as administration’s and some Republicans’ attempt to brand war critics as enablers of terrorism and/or haters of American troops. That’s as equally inaccurate as “General Betray Us.”

The Times just didn’t run an ad at a discount; it helped perpetuate the seemingly inexorable trend towards lowering the bar for mass-media carried political hate speech.

The Times has suffered a series of bungles and image-shattering scandals the past few years. This won’t help it — and as Rupert Murdoch’s Wall Street Journal begins to beef up its news coverage, the Times might do well to look over its shoulder and exercise the kind of care [its “public editor”] Hoyt recommends.

Somewhere, Rupert Murdoch must be smiling.

This was the last thing the Times needed, but above all it was not a slip up in any substantive sense — merely in the sense that it revealed what critics (including me) have long believed to be true: If the New York Times was ever a fair broker, it certainly is not one now.

Posted in Medialites | 1 Comment »

Fake, inaccurate and not actionable

Posted by Ron Coleman on September 19, 2007

Josh Marshall:

Dan Rather files $70 million lawsuit against CBS, Viacom et al.

Good for him.

Heh. No, Josh, I assure you: Good for us! Very, very good for our side!

And even better that Josh Marshall is still drinking from that long-ago Kool-Aid supply. If this schleps into the election, why, it’s double-plus good!

Here’s the story (Marshall didn’t bother to link).

By the way — was he emboldened by Imus’s payoff from the same outfit? You betcha!

Posted in Medialites | 6 Comments »